This earnings call was an absolute embarrassment. MW and PB stumbled to answer every question. MW talked all around the questions, trying to deflect with unrelated context to paint a bigger, more rosy picture. However, the analyst continued to read through this throughout the meeting. While they maintained a somewhat “polite” decorum in the questioning, but they continued to come through with the same theme of “please explain this”, never relenting in seeking to get MW and PB to get to the bottom of the miss. Our executives never “pin pointedly” answered the questions, because if they do - it is game over for their credibility…….at the same time, their credibility still took a big hit b/c of the smoke and mirror answers. The analysts have been asking similar questions for a few years and MW and PB kept “punting” and saying “it will come”………and now it hasn’t……the call yesterday was clearly a lot of deflecting finally coming to a head. They couldn’t answer the questions. Do they truly not understand the questions, or do they not know the answers…….or do they know the answers and now they are in panic mode. PB is retiring……..hmmmm………me thinks he saw this coming. I heard through the grape vine that at MW’s last leadership forum in the spring that he and PB both belittled the extended leaders of business units that they are not doing a good job, not telling the truth around issues and not doing their job. I hear that it was super deflating for the leaders………something about “how leaders react matters”……my boss told me that the reaction by MW and PB was to embarrass a few leaders most directly related with their comments. Midcon and Australia in particular. MW’s seat just got a bit hotter, but the BOD has their backs against the wall with a successor not in place. I presume the investment community will begin to ratchet up the heat on the BOD over the next 12-18 months. CVX has fallen mightily over the last 2 years from the lofty post it once held…….my boss saids MW has a saying, something about leaders changing outcomes……..in this performance/stock dive, I guess the outcomes have changed……but not for the better…….this year the stock price has tanked, this hurts. And it is embarrassing. They can’t buy their way out of this one, but that is what they are trying to do through all these acquisitions….I know my leaders is ultra disappointed, and I suspect he is not the only one…….if MW is loosing his extended leadership team, that is really concerning…..