Thread regarding Wells Fargo & Co. layoffs

Thoughts on Yank & Rank

I've been with the bank for about 5 years right now. Joined straight from college. I always felt that the yank/rank system made no sense and that it was making more damage than good. The process itself was flawed and the management theory behind was weak (at best).

Are there people who work at Wells right now who have experience with different system. I'd be curious to hear what they have to say and how they compare the two paths.

Thank you!!!


by
| 86 views | | 23 replies (last 2 days ago) | Reply
Post ID: @OP+1m7nc6es4

23 replies (most recent on top)

You forgot about wa-k and sp--k. I fight this one eyed cyclops at least 5x a day in the office bathroom then take naps to recover. Unlimited toilet paper and paper towels too. Well, when I choose to clean up. Makes 8 hours RTO a breeze.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @g9+1m7nc6es4

WF is at least 20, probably 30 years beyond in management practices. Some of it is because the industry is insolated against the globalization of the 90s and 00s. Nonetheless, Ford did this in the 90s.....then the firestone fiasco happened and they damn near went bankrupt....

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @g1+1m7nc6es4

@eh this is why actual education in management, even if it was just a few classes added to a STEM degree, becomes important at some point. Leaders needs to be equipped to critically engage with the kinds of hierarchies they are being expected to enforce.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @ey+1m7nc6es4

@en even if there is a sense of competition between coworkers, it is not a good look on any company to actively employ people who cannot regulate their feelings enough to abstain from interpersonal aggression. They can call it being strategic all they want, but it reveals a lack of self control.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @ew+1m7nc6es4

@b5+1m7nc6es4 Agree. Managers can also hand pick who they reach out to, to provide "feedback" on you. People are competitive. They could lie & provide bad feedback.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @en+1m7nc6es4

@ea because the alternative is just management operating on vibes and whatever id--t thinkpiece they most recently read in the WSJ. Which I realize in the norm at Wells, but healthier organizations do try to base their decisions at least somewhat on good data

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @eh+1m7nc6es4

@OP

Manager just lining up their own pockets and throwing everyone else under the bus. Half of manager don’t even understand why their staff knows or does day to day. Why do we have so many managers? What exactly are they managing besides their pocketbooks?

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @eg+1m7nc6es4

@e5 why would anyone look at or trust academic research on this topic.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @ea+1m7nc6es4

Sorry for cutting and pasting an AI summary but it was the quickest way to make this point - dozens of academic studies have been done on stack ranking systems over the years, the findings are crystal clear that this approach to performance management is cancerous to the long term health of organizations. It's not even really a debate.


Academic studies on rank-and-yank (also known as stack ranking or forced distribution rating systems) consistently show that the management practice yields minimal long-term performance gains while generating severe side effects for organizational culture, morale, and retention.

Key Findings from Academic Research

• Marginal Impact on Performance: A meta-analysis of over 100 studies on job insecurity and ranking systems reveals that high-stress, high-insecurity environments yield only weak increases in formal task performance. The real-world utility is largely negligible compared to the psychological toll.
• Punishing High Achievers and Causing Voluntary Turnover: Research published in the Cornell Chronicle highlights that forced distribution caps (e.g., restricting top tiers to 10%–20% of staff) backfire on top talent. Employees who deserve top ratings but are denied them due to arbitrary cutoffs are at least 34% more likely to leave voluntarily within 18 months, even when handed larger financial bonuses meant to compensate for the lower rating.
• Erosion of Collaboration and Pro-Social Behavior: Experimental and behavioral studies (such as recent work on spillover effects from competitive ranking systems published in the Journal of Economic Psychology) demonstrate that rank-and-yank crowds out "other-regarding" behavior. Rather than cooperating, employees engage in internal competition, sabotage, and a decline in helpful citizenship behaviors toward colleagues.
• Increased Systemic Costs and "Quiet Quitting": Research indicates that high job insecurity drives up destructive workplace actions, including absenteeism, reduced safety performance, and quiet quitting. While a two-part experiment noted that firing the bottom tier can artificially lift short-term metrics, the "survivor effect" leaves remaining staff disengaged and distrustful.
• Adverse Impact and Bias Risks: Foundational studies in the Journal of Applied Psychology ("Forced distribution rating systems: when does 'rank and yank' lead to adverse impact?") show that ranking structures frequently introduce systemic bias and legal risks regarding disparate impact against protected classes, as managers are forced to label solid employees as "failures" to satisfy a mathematical distribution curve rather than actual performance standards.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @e5+1m7nc6es4

Stack ranking is a terrible, outdated system with absolutely no real benefits, in my opinion. Chase does it as well, and it’s just as detrimental. These systems don’t motivate people or improve performance, they discourage and demoralize employees while undermining even good managers who are trying to build strong, collaborative teams.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @e4+1m7nc6es4

The model breaks after year 2. It creates incredible stress

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @e3+1m7nc6es4

@d8 My thoughts exactly, which is why I don’t think leadership it trying to motivate us. They want attrition and they don’t want to pay severance for it.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @dh+1m7nc6es4

Those of us who have been here for 10 years or more would agree with your assessment. When the company artificially decides that there must be a certain percentage of inconsistently meats, also known as those who are failing and need to be managed out. You've created a scenario where year over year solid performers eventually get pushed to the bottom. Just by the way the numbers need to work.

At the same time they artificially restrict who can be an "exceeds", where top performers are not being recognized consistently. If you get it one year you get told the next year that you can't have it again because someone else needs to be recognized . Many groups can only allow one or two people to receive that designation each cycle.

All of this eventually impacts pay and promotion regardless of which end of the spectrum you are on. And 80% of employees are trapped in a "meets" designation regardless of what they do. How can that be motivating???

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @d8+1m7nc6es4

@ad in my experience, this also caused employees to not have any idea on what they should be improving on. Internal notes were taken about employees, but employees had no real feedback about what they could/should be working on to improve.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @b9+1m7nc6es4

@aj And how are you”poor performers” even recognized as poor performers? It tends to happen by one employee being ostracized, then passed along to other teams that also ostracize them, which never really gives them a chance to improve.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @b8+1m7nc6es4

It’s antithetical to how humans and the rest of our institutions operate and should be a liability. If someone develops cancer or another serious condition(which everyone can), they’re probably not going to convince a physician to order tests until it starts impacting their work performance. By the time their doctors will get them a diagnosis, adequate treatment, and agree to fill out paperwork for short-term disability, employers are likely to have already laid off or fired them for performance issues. The employee will then go broke by paying for COBRA until they can’t afford it anymore and have to forgo treatment altogether, which will put them at risk of death. Maybe this is by design, but exploiting the system like they do is eventually going to get back to them.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @b7+1m7nc6es4

In my experience, your manager knows nothing about you because they don't actually work with you. All of that is delegated to others, product managers etc. They are 'busy' managing up. They do rank and yank, but it's very subjective, and when they try to use objective metrics, they are clearly bullsh*t.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @b5+1m7nc6es4

WF is the worst. It is fairer at other banks & based on merit, not whose d--k you s---k.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @b4+1m7nc6es4

The issue Wells has is that there is no upside. You are unlikely to get exceeds, promoted, a good merit raise, better bonus, or anything else. There are very few job openings posted P4 and above. Why would anyone work hard for free? People work just hard enough to avoid getting fired and then barely. The incentives are heavily skewed towards political infighting and mediocrity.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @b0+1m7nc6es4

@a2 Very True. Poor performers get passed along like hot potatoes rather than shown the door. After a few years, no want to burn any calories dealing with them

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @aj+1m7nc6es4

It doesn’t make sense because most of the managers don’t have the first clue on how to manage talent. They rose to their position because they were good at managing up and telling their leaders what they wanted to hear, even if it was completely false. In my opinion, there isn’t sufficient accountability.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @a3+1m7nc6es4

I think most would agree its an imperfect system. However WF has such lousy managers that literally nobody would ever get let go for performance ever if the company didnt hold the managers feet to the fire. When managers have poor performers and dont do anything about it the company can either get rid of the managers (which opens another can of worms since most managers are also managed by mo--ns) or it can force the managers to make a decision about who their weakest people are. Everyone on here claims their teams full of elite performers and that its an injustice to get rid of anyone but, statistically, that simply isnt true. Now these lousy managers still manage to pick the wrong people to get rid of oftentimes but the company is so clueless it honestly doesnt know who works hard and who doesnt.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @a2+1m7nc6es4

Post a reply

: