You and many others are missing the point. I think most would agree cuts need to be made but don’t call it performance based when it clearly is not. I’ve known several to go that had always been solid and in the middle unfortunately this year they were in groups with too many of the same type of people and placed in that 8%. It wasn’t based on performance but on “soft skills”. Which are important but not everyone is going to stand up pound there chest and say look what I did today.
Not everyone is built that way and if we continue to remove those that have different personalities we ended up with a culture that is all the same with no open opinions and different view points. The organization will stifle because original thoughts won’t be valued.