We've had two people leave our team over the past few months, and we've finally got one replacement. The problem is that the new hire seems completely unprepared for the job. I don't have an issue with hiring younger or less experienced people. Plenty of them are smart, capable and quick to learn. But this person seems to lack even the most basic knowledge needed for the role. How are these hiring decisions being made? There are plenty of talented candidates out there, so why does it feel like we're settling for whoever happens to apply?
13 replies (most recent on top)
@f3 the new hires are brought on board by the Alvind "Vindalooo Curry" process.
They don't need to know anything but just nod their heads in agreement when Alvind says something, anything at meetings. IBM can't bring in any more H1B visa folks as they used to do previously.
IBM only hires cheap bodies, skills do not matter. They are all expandable any time.
Major parts of IBM US started slowly nudging first line managers and tech leads out of the hiring process around 2010. Formerly, hiring was a mutual veto system where the hiring manager’s top employees, their peer managers, and their reports-to line plus the VP’s technical quality control officer all had to approve a technical hire. A single nay vote ki-led the hire. Now HR and VPs do the hiring. Even if the new employee is capable, they are often placed in the wrong group. More often than not over the past decade, new hires have been a total surprise to their manager.
@aa - Can confirm; when I was hired 5 years ago I went through a traditional "interviewed by the hiring manager and team leader" process. But now, this fall, my manager has been assigned 2 new hires that he has never seen or talked to. They were hired in a group by some arcane process and then randomly assigned to teams. The manager meets them the same time the team does.
The answer to your question about the horrendous hiring IBM does is quickly answered by watching this internal leaked video. Arvind being from India and their caste system, views people by hierarchy and IBM CFO and HR view people by $'s. $ is ALWAYS BETTER than $$ or $$$ or $$$$ etc. Arvind and the Chairman of Red Hat openly and arrogantly defy US Federal Laws about bragging hiring based on age, s-x, gender, religion, skin color etc etc. Arvind demands they discriminate in hiring or suffer not getting their bloated exec bonus's.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrfVIbXKqtg
The level of incompetence at IBM is in the next level... Just observe most of the managers in any project... They have lack of tech knowledge, lazy and not even able to give any single advice.
That's IBM my friend.
@ba In Albany, many have come to recognize that there is little point in pursuing advancement when the same select few favorites consistently receive preferential treatment. It becomes a losing proposition, particularly when other organizations and companies offer a more structured, transparent, and merit-based approach to career progression - one that actually operates in accordance with its formally stated policies and processes. As a result, people increasingly choose to seek greener pastures elsewhere.
All the young people at my site leave after 2 years for many reasons, they see how long term employees are abused by IBM, they see the age discrimination, they don't want to be working on non-competitive second-rate technology like the hybrid cloud or old obsolete 1960s tech like mainframes, they also don't want to be part of a dying mis-managed company that lost $70 Billion of market value in one day etc etc. We actually have a pool taking bets of how long a new hire will stay.
Is it someone from Ind/i/a?
When they hire young people in my area, everyone automatically assumes they aren't the best and brightest since they could apparently only get hired by IBM.
There is an absolutely frightening drought in hard skills and work ethic at IBM. The level of incompetence is practically unbearable.
I am suprised you actually get someone to actually join IBM. Much better options out there
In recent years, managers do not include technical leaders into the hiring decisions, the technical leaders are informed about new hires afterwards.