I agree with most of your points but don't think the h1b1 Indian workers are relatively cheaper. It's the Indian offshore workers that are cheap. I noticed this when I applied for a role in my team that I was definitely qualified for. It would have been a promotion for me. Instead my manager hired an external candidate that is an Indian h1b1 worker from out of state! I think my manager got incentivized to hire the Indian h1b1 worker because I had similar skills but more experience than the h1b1 worker.
I suggest everyone to take a close look at the bulletin boards in the kitchenette in Massachusetts offices. HR are legally required to post these jobs and salary in the office. If you see the job postings on Workday for anyone in Massachusetts to apply AND see physical copies posted in the office, that means the company is intentionally hiring h1b1 workers over more qualified local workers. I saw the job req that I applied for posted on Quincy JAB office.
More info:
By law, employers must provide notice of the filing at the actual place of employment, which includes office locations in Massachusetts.
The notification requirements under U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) regulations (20 CFR § 655.734) can be fulfilled through U.S. Department of Labor Fact Sheet #62M:
• Physical Posting: Hardcopy notices must be displayed at two conspicuous locations at the physical worksite/office in Massachusetts for at least 10 business days, on or within 30 days before the LCA is filed.