It's been completely and consistently trashed for years on both review sites in probably close to 100 reviews by people posting non-anonymously, in ways where the store owner is allowed to give feedback. Associates are named repeatedly, again over the course of years as are managers. And now execs from Hoffman get upset? Everyone in the whole chain of oversight should be fired.
Nor is 1171 isolated. You see similar kinds of complaints at Sears all over the country, mostly complaining about the terrible Innovel delivery service, rude associates, associates nowhere to be found upon checkout, associates refusing to leave their areas, waiting forever because of having to register people for SWYR, constant upselling, broken promises for PA and other warranty agreements. You can see Eddie's stupid metrics that have nothing to do with what "members" actually care about behind all of these. Every other business in the world is paying their reviews close mind, but Sears is checked out and nobody's home.