I am just watching and see 2 groups arguing here. Seniors vs the juniors.
But regardless, the people who actually hold the power of the pen (with regards to making decisions on PA, increments and promotions) shall have the final say here, and in the real world.
It thus boils down to the SHs and higher ups, who decide.
So votings (for, or against), in this forum, carry little meaning and no weight - except for peer group consolation!